Hulley Enterprises Limited (Cyprus) v. Russian Federation, UNCITRAL, PCA Case No. 2005-03/AA226
Case type:
Claimant(s):
Hulley Enterprises Limited (Cyprus)
Respondent state:
Applicable arbitration rules:
Investment treaty:
Applicable legal instruments:
Available documents
Opinion on Provisional Application of the Energy Charter Treaty by Prof. Igor Lukashuk (not public)
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Other expert(s):
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
21
Feb 2006
Opinion on Certain Issues of Arbitrability by Prof. Alexey Kostin (not public)
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Other expert(s):
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
21
Feb 2006
Expert Opinion on the Constitutional Legal Aspects of the Conclusion and Application of International Treaties of the Russian Federation by Prof. Suren Avakiyan (not public)
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Other expert(s):
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
22
Feb 2006
Opinion on the Issue of Possibility of a Shareholder’s Claims against Counter-Parties of the Joint-Stock Company in Connection with Damage Caused by the Latter to the Company by Prof. Yevgeny Sukhanov (not public)
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Other expert(s):
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
22
Feb 2006
Legal Opinion by Prof. Andrey Lisitsyn-Svetlanov (on the meaning of "foreign investment" under Russian law) (not public)
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Other expert(s):
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
26
Feb 2006
Opinion on Provisional Application of International Treaties according to the Constitution of the Russian Federation by Dr. Marat Baglay (not public)
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Other expert(s):
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
22
Jun 2006
Energy Charter Treaty Arbitration: Jurisdiction Issues by Prof. James Crawford, SC (not public)
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Other expert(s):
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
28
Jun 2006
Opinion concerning Arbitral Jurisdiction under the European Energy Charter Treaty with Respect to the Russian Federation in the Yukos Case by Prof. W. Michael Reisman (not public)
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Other expert(s):
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
29
Jun 2006
Opinion concerning the Provisional Application of the Energy Charter Treaty by the Russian Federation by Mr. Vladimir Gladyshev (not public)
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Other expert(s):
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
27
Oct 2006
Expert Opinion on the Provisional Application of International Treaties in the Finnish Constitutional Law Context, especially with regard to the Energy Charter Treaty by Prof. Martti Koskenniemi (not public)
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Other expert(s):
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
31
Oct 2006
Opinion concerning Provisional Application of Article 26 of the Energy Charter Treaty from an International and German Constitutional Law Perspective by Prof. Georg Nolte (not public)
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Other expert(s):
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
12
Dec 2006
Report of the Ministry of Justice of the Russian Federation by Deputy Minister S.V. Vasilyvev (not public)
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Other expert(s):
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
13
Dec 2006
Legal Opinion on the Provisional Application of a Treaty under French Constitutional Law (Taking the Example of the Energy Charter Treaty) by Prof. Alain Pellet (not public)
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Other expert(s):
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
14
Dec 2006
Witness Statement concerning the Provisional Application of the Energy Charter Treaty by Mr. Anatoly Martynov (not public)
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Other expert(s):
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
30
Dec 2006
Legal Opinion by Prof. Gerhard Hafner (not public)
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Other expert(s):
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
17
Jan 2007
Opinion concerning the Provisional Application of the Energy Charter Treaty by the Russian Federation by Prof. Angelika Nussberger (not public)
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Other expert(s):
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
19
Jan 2007
Expert Witness Statement by Prof. Myron Nordquist (on provisional application of the compulsory dispute settlement provisions of the ECT by the Russian Federation) (not public)
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Other expert(s):
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
19
Jan 2007
Expert Comments regarding Expert Opinion of V. Gladyshev dated June 29, 2006 by Prof. Suren Avakiyan (not public)
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Other expert(s):
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
21
Jan 2007
Opinion Concerning the Provisional Application of the Energy Charter Treaty by Mr. Sydney Fremantle (not public)
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Other expert(s):
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
22
Jan 2007
Opinion on the Scope of the Term “Taxation Measures” in the Energy Charter Treaty by Prof. Daniel Berman (not public)
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Other expert(s):
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
22
Jan 2007
Witness Statement by Mr. Stephen Knipler (on coverage of measures relating to taxation in ECT) (not public)
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Other expert(s):
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
29
Jan 2007
Expert Witness Report by Prof. Stef van Weeghel (on entitlement to taxation benefits of the Cyprus-Russia double taxation convention) (not public)
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Other expert(s):
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
2
May 2007
Second Opinion concerning the Provisional Application of the Energy Charter Treaty by the Russian Federation by Mr. Vladimir Gladyshev (not public)
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Other expert(s):
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
3
May 2007
Further Opinion on Energy Charter Treaty Arbitration: Jurisdiction Issues by Prof. James Crawford (not public)
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Other expert(s):
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
29
Jan 2009
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
30
Nov 2009
Claimant appointee:
Respondent appointee:
Arbitrator(s):
Chair/President:
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
1
Apr 2011
First Expert Report of Professor H. David Rosenbloom (not public)
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Respondent's expert:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
17
Jan 2012
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
14
Mar 2012
Expert Report of Mr. Philip Baker QC (not public)
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Claimant's expert:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
15
Aug 2012
Second Expert Report of Professor H. David Rosenbloom (not public)
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Respondent's expert:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
18
Jul 2014
Claimant appointee:
Respondent appointee:
Arbitrator(s):
Chair/President:
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
31
Jul 2014
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
30
Oct 2014
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Respondent's expert:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
8
Nov 2014
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Respondent's expert:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
28
Jan 2015
Writ of Summons (not public)
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Country in which this occurs:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
20
Oct 2015
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Country in which this occurs:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
20
Oct 2015
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Country in which this occurs:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
20
Oct 2015
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Country in which this occurs:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
20
Oct 2015
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Country in which this occurs:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
20
Oct 2015
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Country in which this occurs:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
20
Oct 2015
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Country in which this occurs:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
20
Oct 2015
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Country in which this occurs:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
20
Oct 2015
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Country in which this occurs:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
17
Dec 2015
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
9
Feb 2016
Arbitrator(s):
Chair/President:
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
12
Feb 2016
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
20
Apr 2016
Arbitrator(s):
Chair/President:
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
28
Apr 2016
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
30
Sep 2016
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
21
Oct 2016
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
23
Nov 2016
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
19
Jun 2017
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
19
Jun 2017
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
27
Jun 2017
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
27
Jun 2017
Arbitrator(s):
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
30
Jun 2017
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
18
Aug 2017
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
28
Nov 2017
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
9
Dec 2017
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
25
Sep 2018
Arbitrator(s):
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
18
Feb 2020
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
25
Sep 2020
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
20
Nov 2020
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
20
Nov 2020
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
20
Nov 2020
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
4
Dec 2020
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Country in which this occurs:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
14
Apr 2021
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Country in which this occurs:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
23
Apr 2021
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Country in which this occurs:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
5
Nov 2021
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Country in which this occurs:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
10
Dec 2021
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
17
Dec 2021
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
13
Apr 2022
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Country in which this occurs:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
13
Apr 2022
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Country in which this occurs:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
28
Jun 2022
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Country in which this occurs:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
18
Aug 2022
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Country in which this occurs:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
26
Oct 2022
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
26
Oct 2022
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Country in which this occurs:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
28
Nov 2022
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Country in which this occurs:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
13
Jun 2023
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
9
Aug 2023
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
22
Sep 2023
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
2
Oct 2023
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
1
Nov 2023
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
17
Nov 2023
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
19
Jan 2024
Claimant appointee:
Respondent appointee:
Arbitrator(s):
Chair/President:
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
20
Feb 2024
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
22
Mar 2024
Claimant appointee:
Respondent appointee:
Arbitrator(s):
Chair/President:
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
17
Jun 2024
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
12
Feb 2025
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Country in which this occurs:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
11
Apr 2025
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Country in which this occurs:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
25
Jul 2025
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Country in which this occurs:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
5
Aug 2025
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Country in which this occurs:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members: