William Richard Clayton, Douglas Clayton, Daniel Clayton, and Bilcon of Delaware, Inc. v. Government of Canada, PCA Case No. 2009-04
Case type:
Claimant(s):
Clayton, Bilcon of Delaware Inc.
Respondent state:
Applicable arbitration rules:
Investment treaty:
Applicable legal instruments:
Economic sector:
Outcome:
Amount of damages:
US $7,000,000
Other remedy:
Canada shall pay interest on the amount awarded at a rate of the average one-year U.S. Treasury bill yield for the corresponding calendar year, accruing annually on a compounded basis, starting on 22 October 2007 and until full payment of the sum awarded.
Available documents
5
Feb 2008
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
26
May 2008
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
30
Jan 2009
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
9
Apr 2009
Arbitrator(s):
Chair/President:
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
4
May 2009
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
4
May 2009
Arbitrator(s):
Chair/President:
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
3
Jun 2009
Arbitrator(s):
Chair/President:
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
17
Jul 2009
Arbitrator(s):
Chair/President:
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
24
Jul 2009
Arbitrator(s):
Chair/President:
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
26
Aug 2009
Arbitrator(s):
Chair/President:
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
20
Nov 2009
Arbitrator(s):
Chair/President:
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
25
Nov 2009
Arbitrator(s):
Chair/President:
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
3
Dec 2009
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
18
Dec 2009
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
16
Jul 2010
Arbitrator(s):
Chair/President:
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
2
Sep 2010
Arbitrator(s):
Chair/President:
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
25
Jun 2011
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
8
Jul 2011
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Claimant's expert:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
10
Aug 2011
Arbitrator(s):
Chair/President:
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
2
Dec 2011
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Respondent's expert:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
7
Dec 2011
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Respondent's expert:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
9
Dec 2011
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
21
Dec 2011
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
2
May 2012
Arbitrator(s):
Chair/President:
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
11
Jul 2012
Arbitrator(s):
Chair/President:
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
19
Sep 2012
Arbitrator(s):
Chair/President:
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
17
Oct 2012
Arbitrator(s):
Chair/President:
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
15
Nov 2012
Arbitrator(s):
Chair/President:
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
19
Dec 2012
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Claimant's expert:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
21
Dec 2012
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
23
Jan 2013
Arbitrator(s):
Chair/President:
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
21
Mar 2013
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Respondent's expert:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
21
Mar 2013
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
16
Apr 2013
Arbitrator(s):
Chair/President:
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
19
Apr 2013
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
15
Oct 2013
Arbitrator(s):
Chair/President:
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
22
Oct 2013
Arbitrator(s):
Chair/President:
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
23
Oct 2013
Arbitrator(s):
Chair/President:
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
24
Oct 2013
Arbitrator(s):
Chair/President:
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Other counsel:
,
Other counsel:
,
Other counsel:
,
Other counsel:
,
Other counsel:
,
Other counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
25
Oct 2013
Arbitrator(s):
Chair/President:
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
28
Oct 2013
Arbitrator(s):
Chair/President:
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
29
Oct 2013
Arbitrator(s):
Chair/President:
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
30
Oct 2013
Arbitrator(s):
Chair/President:
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
31
Oct 2013
Arbitrator(s):
Chair/President:
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
10
Mar 2015
Claimant appointee:
Respondent appointee:
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
17
Mar 2015
Claimant appointee:
Respondent appointee:
Arbitrator(s):
Chair/President:
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
16
Jun 2015
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
10
Aug 2015
Arbitrator(s):
Chair/President:
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
20
Apr 2016
Claimant appointee:
Respondent appointee:
Arbitrator(s):
Chair/President:
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
6
Jun 2016
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
14
Feb 2017
Claimant appointee:
Respondent appointee:
Arbitrator(s):
Chair/President:
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
22
Feb 2017
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
10
Mar 2017
Claimant appointee:
Respondent appointee:
Arbitrator(s):
Chair/President:
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
26
Apr 2017
Claimant appointee:
Respondent appointee:
Arbitrator(s):
Chair/President:
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
14
Aug 2017
Claimant appointee:
Respondent appointee:
Arbitrator(s):
Chair/President:
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
6
Nov 2017
Claimant appointee:
Respondent appointee:
Arbitrator(s):
Chair/President:
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
17
Nov 2017
Claimant appointee:
Respondent appointee:
Arbitrator(s):
Chair/President:
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
8
Dec 2017
Claimant appointee:
Respondent appointee:
Arbitrator(s):
Chair/President:
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
29
Dec 2017
Claimant appointee:
Respondent appointee:
Arbitrator(s):
Chair/President:
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
15
Jan 2018
Claimant appointee:
Respondent appointee:
Arbitrator(s):
Chair/President:
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
6
Feb 2018
Claimant appointee:
Respondent appointee:
Arbitrator(s):
Chair/President:
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
19
Feb 2018
Claimant appointee:
Respondent appointee:
Arbitrator(s):
Chair/President:
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
20
Feb 2018
Claimant appointee:
Respondent appointee:
Arbitrator(s):
Chair/President:
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
21
Feb 2018
Claimant appointee:
Respondent appointee:
Arbitrator(s):
Chair/President:
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
22
Feb 2018
Claimant appointee:
Respondent appointee:
Arbitrator(s):
Chair/President:
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
23
Feb 2018
Claimant appointee:
Respondent appointee:
Arbitrator(s):
Chair/President:
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
24
Feb 2018
Claimant appointee:
Respondent appointee:
Arbitrator(s):
Chair/President:
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
26
Feb 2018
Claimant appointee:
Respondent appointee:
Arbitrator(s):
Chair/President:
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
28
Feb 2018
Claimant appointee:
Respondent appointee:
Arbitrator(s):
Chair/President:
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
2
May 2018
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
10
Jan 2019
Claimant appointee:
Respondent appointee:
Arbitrator(s):
Chair/President:
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
10
Jan 2019
Claimant appointee:
Respondent appointee:
Arbitrator(s):
Chair/President:
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
8
May 2019
Claimant appointee:
Respondent appointee:
Arbitrator(s):
Chair/President:
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
24
Nov 2022
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Country in which this occurs:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members:
24
Jul 2024
Arbitrator(s):
Judges:
Claimant's counsel:
Respondent's counsel:
Country in which this occurs:
Annulment Committee president:
Annulment Committee members: